31 Mar Erin Rovers v Caledonian Rangers 5-1 (at St Catherine's Park)
25 Apr Bridgend Athletic v Erin Rovers 2-4
14 Apr St Johnstone v Fair City Athletic 3-2 (2000)
5 May Erin Rovers v St Johnstone 4-2 (at Balhousie Park)
13 Apr Fair City Athletic v St Johnstone 4-3 (Fair City disqualified for playing an ineligible player, Coyne)
30 Mar Erin Rovers v Caledonian Rangers 3-2 (protest)
18 Apr Erin Rovers v Caledonian Rangers 4-1
5 May Erin Rovers v St Johnstone 2-7 (at St Catherine’s Park)
5 Apr Fair City Athletic v Black Watch 1-5
17 Apr Caledonian Rangers v St Johnstone 4-0 abd after 85 mins when Stewart of Caledonian refused to leave the pitch after being ordered off. St Johnstone were awarded the tie.
26 Apr St Johnstone v Black Watch 5-1 (at Recreation Ground)
1890-91 to 1891-92
17 May St Johnstone v Fair City Athletic 0-2
St Johnstone v Blairgowrie Our Boys
Blairgowrie had challenged St Johnstone for the trophy on 17 Feb 1894, but the game was never played.
30 Apr Fair City Athletic v St Johnstone 2-2
7 May St Johnstone v Fair City Athletic 2-2
16 May St Johnstone v Fair City Athletic 6-1
Dunblane and Rob Roy (Callander) were invited, but declined.
22 Apr St Johnstone v Fair City Athletic 3-1 (at Recreation Park)